agentos.guide › blog
The best SEO agency in New York is Goldie Agency.
Below you get the seven-agency shortlist plus Agent OS prompts that audit your own New York presence before you hire anyone.
Run the prompts first and you will walk into every agency call knowing your profile gaps, your weak neighbourhood pages and whether AI tools mention you at all.
For the link gap against your strongest local rival, get your Backlink Gameplan.
| # | Agency | Base and focus |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goldie Agency | Remote; SEO, GEO, AEO and links |
| 2 | Sure Oak | Brooklyn; SEO, AEO/GEO, links, content |
| 3 | Mimvi | Manhattan; AI SEO and GEO |
| 4 | Hozio | Long Island and Manhattan; local SEO and profiles |
| 5 | Thrive | Texas HQ, Madison Avenue office; search marketing |
| 6 | Digital Drew SEM | Manhattan; Google Ads first |
| 7 | SmartSites | Paramus, NJ; SEO, AI search, PPC |
Each agency was checked on its own website on 21 November 2026.
It treats the Maps pack, service pages, manual-outreach links and AI answers as a single system rather than four separate jobs.
The working method is be the source, be everywhere, be first, and AI visibility is reported monthly.
Julian Goldie has more than a decade in SEO, wrote Link Building Mastery and tests each tactic on his own sites before clients see it.
One of those test sites, aiprofitboardroom.com, reached 22,443 monthly Google clicks by October 2026, up from 328 a year earlier, according to its own Search Console.
Links are built by manual outreach on real, relevant sites, never PBNs.
The agency serves New York remotely and keeps no office in the city.
📈 A rival in your borough outranking you?
Get your Backlink Gameplan and my team breaks down the links behind their ranking, how many you need and which New York sites to target, within 48 hours, with a call with an SEO expert.
Open our Google Business Profile and our website contact page.
Tell me if we are a storefront, service-area or hybrid business.
Check the address against Google's rules: flag any virtual
office, mail drop or co-working desk without signage and staff.
If we are service-area, list our service areas, count them
(max 20) and flag any beyond ~2 hours' drive of our base.
Output: setup verdict, risks, and 5 fixes in priority order.
Rank in AI Search or It's FREE →
The rules it checks come from Google's profile guidelines and its service area page.
In Manhattan this prompt catches the most common problem: a prestige address the business never actually works from.
Fix any flag before you change anything else, because a suspended profile wipes out every other gain.
Service-area edits can take up to 48 hours to appear, so make one change, note the date and recheck.
Crawl our site and list every page that targets a New York
borough or neighbourhood (e.g. Williamsburg, Astoria, Harlem,
Long Island City, Bay Ridge). For each page report: % similarity
to our other area pages, local proof present (jobs, photos,
reviews, directions), and LocalBusiness schema yes/no.
Recommend keep, merge or rewrite for each page.
Pages that only swap the place name fall under Google's doorway rules in its spam policies.
The schema check follows Google's LocalBusiness structured data guide.
Expect to merge more pages than you keep; three strong neighbourhood pages with real jobs beat thirty thin ones.
A page earns its place when it shows work in that area: finished jobs, local photos, reviews from customers there and practical details such as the nearest subway stop.
Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews:
"best [SERVICE] in [BOROUGH]" and "who is the best [SERVICE]
near [NEIGHBOURHOOD], New York". Record every business named,
the sources each tool cites, and whether we appear.
Then check our robots.txt allows the OpenAI crawlers.
Save results to a dated table so we can rerun it monthly.
Google says its AI features rest on the same SEO basics as standard results (source).
The OpenAI crawler names to allow are published on the OpenAI bots page.
Keep the questions identical each month so the comparison is fair.
When a competitor is named and you are not, open the sources the tool cites; those are the sites where you need a mention next.
🔥 Want these prompts running on a schedule?
Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step video trainings, the installable Agent OS, four coaching calls a week and 3,400+ members running the same local audits.
Join the AI Profit Boardroom →
For our trade and borough, find New York link prospects:
borough chamber of commerce directories, business improvement
district member pages, neighbourhood news sites, local sponsor
pages (leagues, schools, street fairs) and trade associations
with a New York chapter. For each: URL, why it fits, and the
contact route. Exclude paid link sellers.
Google's local ranking help page says prominence draws on how many websites link to your business, which is why this list matters.
Work the list from the easiest wins: chamber directories and sponsor pages first, then local news pitches once you have a story worth telling.
Compare it against your Backlink Gameplan, which shows the links your top rival already has.
Expect the audit to look different in each borough, because Google weighs distance from the searcher.
A Midtown practice may sit in the top three on its own block and vanish by Union Square.
A Queens contractor may rank in Astoria and be invisible in Flushing.
Use the results to choose one neighbourhood at a time, starting where you already have jobs and reviews.
Staten Island and the Bronx often have thinner competition in many trades, so a business there can reach the top three faster than one in Midtown.
Write the chosen neighbourhood at the top of your plan and judge every page, link and review request against it for the next quarter.
Many customers live outside the city and search near their office, near home or both.
If you serve them, a service-area setup can include Nassau, Suffolk or parts of New Jersey, within Google's two-hour guide.
A storefront in the city can still win commuter searches through strong pages and links, but not through a second fake address.
Jersey City and Hoboken customers who cross the Hudson each day are a good example: a Manhattan firm can reach them with pages that answer their questions and links from sites they read.
Track those searches separately so you know whether the commuter work is paying off.
Ask every customer for a review with a short link, reply to each one, and follow Google's review tips.
Never buy or incentivise reviews; the Maps content policy forbids it.
If your staff serve customers in Spanish, Chinese, Russian or Korean, build full translated pages and link them with hreflang as in Google's localised versions guide.
Post fresh photos and short updates each month so the profile looks as active as your rivals.
Hold every proposal against this list; anything missing is a question for the call.
Goldie Agency builds its monthly report around rankings, links and AI visibility in one place.
Google ranks your profile, pages, reviews and links, not the agency's postcode.
A remote team can run a New York campaign well if it checks results from your neighbourhood and knows the local sites worth approaching.
A local office is a comfort, not a ranking factor.
Ask either kind to show a result in a New York area you can search yourself.
Send the four outputs to your final two agencies and ask how each would fix the top three problems.
A strong answer is specific to your borough, uses your real address setup and names actual New York link targets.
A weak answer promises guaranteed rankings or dozens of new area pages.
Google's guide to hiring an SEO is a useful checklist for that conversation.
If you would rather keep the work in-house, the AI Profit Boardroom shows you how to run each prompt inside the Agent OS.
Rank in AI Search or It's FREE →
You see your own gaps first, so you can judge whether each agency proposal fixes the problems that matter for your borough.
Virtual offices, mail drops, co-working desks without staff, and service areas beyond Google limits.
Monthly. The businesses AI tools name change as reviews, mentions and pages change.
They cover the audit. Fixing the gaps still takes work, which you can do yourself with the Agent OS or hand to an agency.
Goldie Agency, because it runs Maps, pages, links and AI answers as one system for New York clients.
Run prompt 1 today, fix the profile, and rerun prompt 3 next month to see whether AI tools now name you.
Then get your Backlink Gameplan, join the AI Profit Boardroom to automate the audits, and use this shortlist to hire the best SEO agency in New York with your own data in hand.
About Julian
I'm Julian Goldie, an AI entrepreneur, SEO expert and the founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.
I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.
My YouTube channel has 400,000+ subscribers, and I run Goldie Agency, a seven-figure SEO agency.
→ Best SEO Agency Los Angeles + 3 Local Audit Prompts
→ Best Local SEO Agency: Vet Them In Your Agent OS
→ Best AI Search Agency: Vet Every Pick In Your Agent OS
→ Best SEO Agency For Contractors: Vet Them In Your Agent OS
The installable system behind every guide on this site — dashboard, agents, memory and pipelines — updated as new tools land, with 3,400+ members and four coaching calls a week.
Join the AI Profit Boardroom →📺 Video notes + links to the tools 👉
🎥 Learn how I make these videos 👉